00:00
00:00
FantasistEldrun

240 Audio Reviews

74 w/ Responses

This isnt a very constructive feedback, but I found the music very well made, and very interesting

Welcome to a Pokemon Diamond edition city

I could pretty well imagine this in a rpg, excellent music anyway

Happy to see the legend is still here and working ! :D

In memories -

Well, fully race-themed, but I would not specially see this in an arctic scene, I could tho imagine it in a city race, or a retro videogame race in a stadium, maybe I'm missing the vibe too... At the whole end it is very ambient, but again, it feels to me more hopeful than specially cold or arctic.

Overall nice song, I like how it feels like "pushing to the greatest" (Sorry I dont know how to tell this)

Overall ranking : 8/10
Theming rank : 6/10

As expected for me very early in the competition, there are plural DnB entries. I am not blaming DnB as it is a genre I like, but well, even when the actual music is more than decent, the style choice has been used many times :/

Excepted that, it feels pretty well the theme, and I dont see much to say about. For this I would need to add a distinction too

Overall ranking : 8/10
Theming rank : 7/10
Contest rank (In all my own criterias that are not to be considerated) : 6/10

Snikio responds:

thank you so much!!
I'll think about ways to refine this and make it even more special

Well, this is not a style I were expecting, this track is pretty original. In the context of the entry, it could really evoke me a race, I have a scene in mind while listening to it, the only thing that perturbates me... Well, since I started to write this before the end of the song, I need to delete what I were writing. Anyway, nice work. Tho the style itself reminds me of pokemon retro games

Overall ranking : 8/10
Theming rank : 8/10

ZuwerWS responds:

If I could ask you, what was the thing you were meaning to write? You got me curious

Well, the drumnbass genre sure gives itself a race theme, a genre that I like too, and the ambience was basically evoking something that felt cold, so it was (I think) a good entry for the theme. Not giving a 10 tho because it was switching between Arctic theme and race theme without evoking both in the same time at any moment in this song - Imo at least. In an overall rank, I would say the music is actually well diriged, ambiancing, but (here is the problem of most of DnB tracks imo) very repetitive from 1:30 to 2:00

Overall ranking : 8/10
Theming rank : 7/10

Honnestly I can feel the Mariokart sounding here, so I see the actual race atmosphere. But I dont feel this so "Arctic themed", I personally already have too much of the mk8's races in mind so it feels more for me like the yoshi circuit of the dlc

Edit : Tbh after listening to the OST of the yoshi's circuit again, I agree it's not very similar. I dont know why I imaginated this circuit in my mind when listening to the song still xD

Overall rating : 8/10
Theming rate : 5/10

Everratic responds:

Thanks for stopping by to leave a review! I listened to the Yoshi's Circuit track from MK8 and couldn't identify the similarity, but I still get that it doesn't fit what you had in mind for an arctic theme.

When you see that purest form of beauty in this world is at the deepest in books, you become a fantasist.
When you think you have to get your goals and you can rush anything for it, it's an "eldrun"
Here for my name's signification

Male

Joined on 7/25/23

Level:
9
Exp Points:
826 / 900
Exp Rank:
84,161
Vote Power:
5.14 votes
Audio Scouts
4
Rank:
Civilian
Global Rank:
> 100,000
Blams:
0
Saves:
5
B/P Bonus:
0%
Whistle:
Normal
Medals:
31